Knowledge Matters

Understanding knowledge relationships

A Review of NetMiner 4: Part 1 - Packages and Licensing

I’m often asked what tools I use for network analysis. Over the years I’ve tried most of them with the exception of Valdis Kreb’s Inflow . I’ve pretty much settled on UCINET/NetDraw because of its wide acceptance in academic circles; NodeXL because of its flexibility and ease of use for quick and dirty tasks; Sentinel Visualizer because of its link analysis, geospatial views, and timelines capabilities; and Cyram NetMiner because it is an all in one package with great visualisation capabilities. Of these Cyram NetMiner is my tool of choice, although unfortunately new licencing arrangements may change that (see below ). I’ve been using NetMiner since its version 2 release in 2005. In May 2011 Cyram released version 4 of NetMiner and I’m very impressed, although it’s not for the faint-hearted or novice! Here’s the first of a multi-part review.

There are eight packages and five licence types to choose from, which personally I found a bit confusing, particularly as some packages are standard to a licence. The packages are:

Basic – the essential package on which everything else is built. It includes 26 data transformation tools like symmetrize, and convert to one-mode network; 28 analysis options, such as centrality, block-modelling and brokerage; an 23 visualisation options, ranging from spring diagrams to concentric circles or targets (which I think are the hallmark diagrams of NetMiner, and which I use extensively).

Advanced Analysis – extends the 28 analysis options to 36 by including measures like homophily and page rank, as well as a number of measures for two-mode networks.

Explore – simply provides a way to explore and reanalyse the results of previous analysis. To my way of thinking this package should be part of the basic package, and therefore is essential.

Advanced Visualisation – provides the capability to draw three dimensional maps as well as contour and surface plots, and heat diagrams.

Statistics –provides 28 statistical measures, such as ANOVA, regression, and correlation.

Tools – provides a query composer, graph editor, and matrix calculator. Again I think the query composer and graph editor should be part of the basic package.

Database – provides the ability to retrieve data from SQL Server and Oracle databases

Script – is an exciting new package that allows Python scripts to be used, the creation of new algorithms, and the automation of repetitive or conditional tasks.

For most users they will be happy with the Basic package plus Explore and Tools. As a power user I decided I wanted the lot!

The five licence types are also confusing, and restrictive. They are:

Student Coursework – a three month standalone licence that includes everything, but is limited by the analysis of 1,000 nodes.

Student Research – an annual licence built on the basic package plus the addition of packages. It varies in cost depending on whether the analysis is for a small network (1,000 nodes), medium network (10,000) nodes, or a large network (100,000 nodes).

Academic – an annual or perpetual standalone licence built on the basic package plus the addition of packages. Again it varies in cost depending on whether the analysis is for a small network (1,000 nodes), medium network (10,000) nodes, or a large network (100,000 nodes). The licence is for non-commercial use.

Institution – a perpetual network licence that includes all packages and is capable of handling 100,000 nodes. The licence is for an institution which performs research and development activities, or a not-for-profit organisation, and which is not affiliated with any commercial operation.

Enterprise - a perpetual network licence that includes all packages and is capable of handling 1,000,000 nodes. There are no restrictions on use.

I settled on a perpetual academic licence with all the packages, capable of running 10,000 nodes. This cost $2,100, so it’s not a trivial investment. I really wanted a commercial licence but given I don’t run a network or use a server this is at the moment problematic. I also understand that Cyram wants to operate on a Royalty basis, which doesn’t work for most small businesses! I’m still in discussion with Cyram about this one. Fortunately I have a commercial perpetual licence for NetMiner 3 to cover my commercial activities

In the coming days I’ll provide a review covering the tools output and scripting capabilities. In short they are awesome!

Regards Graham
 

Comments

Cyram NetMiner Changes the Licencing Arrangements

I've exchanged many emails with Cyram NetMiner since posting this article.  I'm pleased to say that Cyram have decided to change their licencing arrangements, and no royalty fees will apply to small business owners.  A perpetual commercial licence for a small business, with all the packages capable of running 10,000 nodes, is now about $5,000 a seat.  I believe this is money well spent.

Regards Graham

Completely Agree

As a small business owner with tight margins and difficult clients I have to agree that a royalty licence simply will not work. Thats why I mainly use open source tools like Gephi and NodeXL. NetMiner's commercial licence options are too expensive for me. I hope you can talk some sense into them.

Keep up the blogging. There aren't that many good blogs with a SNA/ONA theme!

Hans

NetMiner is Better for Commercial Uses

Thanks for the comment and compliment Hans. I use NodeXL and have played with Gephi - it's hard to beat their price! That said I find NetMiner to be better for commercial uses, mainly because of it's combined analytical and visualization capabilities.

Regards Graham

NetMiner

Graham,very good comments and observations about the great tool by Netminer but essentially limited by some clunky ersatz contractual arrangements. I have looked at this tool as part of businesss development within my company for transformational change tools. We are a multi national prime and after a market survey we found easier companies and tools to deal with initally who had a better value add proposition. So as such, Netminer did not make the short list - a pity. I know these guys are a small concern but I would like to see a more flexible construct to their workload pipeline and income stream. I understand why they have this 'royalty' construct, but honestly, this sort of clunky protectionism is a bit passe. There are many other way theys can contract, alliance and team with companies to achieve their same end state. If I was Netminer I would concentrate on a sales regime of quality and volume instead of attempting a 'one hit wonder' with their income stream. If they can latch onto the coat tails of a major and/or successful concern then they will do well. Keep up the good work and best of luck as it seems you have finally submitted the much vaunted 'thesis.'
 

NetMiner 4 Licencing

Thanks for your comment "Anonymous", and thanks for reading my blog.

In the past I've actually found Cyram fairly easy to deal with, so I'm hopeful we can come to some sort of arrangement such as a  "stand alone commercial perpetual" licence for 10,000 nodes, which was possible in version 3. I'm sure with market feedback, such your comments and mine, they will look at their licencing arrangements.

I've been using version 4 for several weeks now, and I have to tell you it it's awesome.  The new scripting tool seems to be quite powerful. Watch out for the next couple of posts, where I'll take a look at the tools capabilities.

Regards Graham

Copyright © 2004 -2012 Knowledge Matters™ - all rights reserved
The Webpages and Occasional Blog of Graham Durant-Law
E-mail: graham@durantlaw.info

Clicky